Irell & Manella Trial Team Secures $74 Million Patent Infringement Verdict for DVR Market Leader TiV

Looks like TiVo’s lawyers are celebrating with a press release.

Apr 21, 2006 08:45 ET

Irell & Manella Trial Team Secures $74 Million Patent Infringement Verdict for DVR Market Leader TiVo

Jury’s finding of willful infringement by EchoStar means damages could be trebled

LOS ANGELES, Calif., April 21 /PRNewswire/ — In a closely-watched trial involving one of the most popular forms of technology in the home entertainment market, law firm Irell & Manella LLP represented TiVo Inc. in its $74 million patent infringement verdict against EchoStar Communications Corp.

On April 13, a Marshall, Texas jury concluded that EchoStar had willfully infringed TiVo’s patent on its “time-warp” technology for digital video recorders (known as DVRs). Despite two weeks of testimony about complex technology and patent issues, the jurors needed only two hours and fifteen minutes of deliberations to reach the unanimous verdict.

The finding of willful infringement exposes EchoStar to potential treble damages. In addition, EchoStar faces a potential injunction that would preclude it from further distribution of infringing DVRs. TiVo’s general counsel Matthew Zinn noted after the trial that an injunction would be even more meaningful than the sheer dollar award.

Although many companies — EchoStar included — had previously tried to develop DVRs, TiVo was the first to produce successfully and market a low-cost DVR product that allows consumers to pause, rewind, and fast forward a live television program.

Morgan Chu led a team of Irell & Manella attorneys who focused on the different issues in the case. Andrei Iancu focused on the technology and patent issues in the case, while Christine Byrd focused on explaining how TiVo’s business was directly damaged by EchoStar’s infringement and establishing the amount of damages. Perry Goldberg focused on showing that EchoStar was fully aware of TiVo’s patent but nonetheless continued to sell its own DVRs without making any design changes.

“We’re extremely pleased that the jury agreed with our view of the case,” said Morgan Chu, the Irell lawyer who led TiVo’s trial team. “TiVo is a great company whose innovations have forever changed the landscape of the home entertainment industry. While trial lawyers always like to win, doing so for a company that has pushed existing boundaries to create a valuable product makes the verdict even more rewarding.”

Irell has been representing Silicon Valley-based TiVo since January 2000, when the market leader first came under attack from companies looking to profit from the DVR craze. The firm successfully defended TiVo in separate actions by both Gemstar and Pause Technology.

The EchoStar verdict reached in Texas, TiVo’s first against an infringing competitor, is the natural outcome of a comprehensive litigation strategy that Irell has pursued since 2004 when the case was filed.

“Although a trial verdict understandably gets the most attention in a patent suit, the road to obtaining a verdict of infringement is usually paved by a series of wins in extremely complicated pretrial motions and discovery proceedings,” said Mr. Chu. “This case was no different. In large part, our

victory at trial sprang directly from earlier achievements, which included obtaining favorable claim construction and discovery rulings.”

Mr. Chu added: “One of the reasons for our firm’s frequent success is our staffing philosophy. Our IP litigation teams usually include attorneys who are not technologists, in addition to lawyers with technical backgrounds. As a result, we are able to offer clients such as TiVo the best of all possible worlds – complete understanding of the complex technologies at issue in these cases integrated with well-rounded problem-solving perspectives and differentiated skill sets.”

In addition to Mr. Chu, TiVo was represented at trial by Irell attorneys Christine Byrd, Perry Goldberg, Andrei Iancu, Ben Yorks, Alexander Giza, Adam Hoffman, Brian Jones and Michelle Armond, and by local counsel Sam Baxter and Garret Chambers of McKool Smith.


Irell & Manella LLP is a full service law firm with over 205 attorneys in its Southern California offices in Los Angeles and Newport Beach. Founded in 1941, the firm is nationally recognized for its intellectual property, technology transactions, entertainment, tax, litigation, corporate and securities practices. Irell was named the Number One U.S. law firm for intellectual property by Chambers in 2005. For more on the firm, visit .

From: Lauren Holz 212-262-7482

Megan Weinsten 310-277-7538

Source: Irell & Manella

CONTACT: Lauren Holz, +1-212-262-7482,, or Megan
Weinsten, +1-310-277-7538,, both for Irell & Manella

Web site:

About MegaZone

MegaZone is the Editor of Gizmo Lovers and the chief contributor. He's been online since 1989 and active in several generations of 'social media' - mailing lists, USENet groups, web forums, and since 2003, blogging.    MegaZone has a presence on several social platforms: Google+ / Facebook / Twitter / LinkedIn / LiveJournal / Web.    You can also follow Gizmo Lovers on other sites: Blog / Google+ / Facebook / Twitter.
This entry was posted in Press Release, TiVo. Bookmark the permalink.